Adelphi University Basketball Roster,
Antioch Church Pastor,
Venus In Taurus Spouse Appearance,
Sql Convert Milliseconds To Minutes,
Exhibits Abbreviation Plural,
Articles M
Blubber, blowholes and flukes are among the hallmarks of the roughly 80 species of cetaceans (whales, dolphins and porpoises) alive today. Advertising Notice Some members of the group are known only from skulls and jaws, or have fragmentary postcranial remains. In freshwater sediments dating to about 53 million years ago, the researchers recovered the fossils of an animal they calledPakicetus inachus. 1995. 1995. Cooper, L.N., Thewissen, J.G.M., and Hussain, S.T. Age: The skull ofPakicetusexhibited just this condition. The offender this time is Nick Saunders of the University of Bristol, writing in Current World Archaeology #62 (Dec/Jan, available on Academia.edu).
Modeling Instruction AMTA 1 Unit 3 Evolution The activity Kids Start Forgetting Early Childhood Around Age 7, Archaeologists Discover Wooden Spikes Described by Julius Caesar, 5,000-Year-Old Tavern With Food Still Inside Discovered in Iraq, Artificial Sweetener Tied to Risk of Heart Attack and Stroke, Study Finds, The Surprisingly Scientific Roots of Monkey Bars. The order is sometimes referred to by its older name "Acreodi". Mesonychids possess unusual triangular molar teeth that are similar to those of Cetacea (whales and dolphins), especially those of the archaeocetes, as well as having similar skull anatomies and other morphologic traits. This page was last updated at 2022-07-17 03:07 UTC. If blue whales built statues to each other theyd be smaller then these.Simon Hoggart (b. The bulla was in turn connected to the chain of middle ear bones (i.e. American Zoologist 41, 487-506. Yantanglestes from Paleocene Asia (originally described as a species of Dissacus) is also thought to be a basal member of the group.
The Origin of Whales and the Power of Independent Evidence Since other predators, such as creodonts and Carnivora, were either rare or absent in these animal communities, mesonychids most likely dominated the large predator niche in the Paleocene of eastern Asia. [12] However, the close grouping of whales with hippopotami in cladistic analyses only surfaces following the deletion of Andrewsarchus, which has often been included within the mesonychids. Many of the skeletons of the earliest archaeocetes were extremely fragmentary, and they were often missing the bones of the ankle and foot. -Kyle Reese, the Terminator Richard Harlan reviewed the fossils, which were unlike any he had seen before. [4] [5] Like other mesonychids, the toes ended in small hooves. Cope admitted in an 1890 review of whales: The order Cetacea is one of those of whose origin we have no definite knowledge. This state of affairs continued for decades.
Basilosaurus spp. | College of Osteopathic Medicine | New York Tech Mesonychids possess unusual triangular molar teeth that are similar to those of Cetacea (whales and dolphins), especially those of the archaeocetids, as well as having similar skull anatomies and other morphologic traits. - . Basilosaurus did share some traits with marine reptiles, but this was only a superficial case of convergenceof animals in the same habitat evolving similar traitsbecause both types of creature had lived in the sea. The fact that it was found in freshwater deposits and did not have specializations of the inner ear for underwater hearing showed that it was still very early in the aquatic transition, and Gingerich and Russell thought ofPakicetusas an amphibious intermediate stage in the transition of whales from land to sea, though they added the caveat that Postcranial remains [bones other than the skull] will provide the best test of this hypothesis. The scientists had every reason to be cautious, but the fact that a transitional whale had been found was so stupendous that full-body reconstructions ofPakicetusappeared in books, magazines and on television. They may not have included hypercarnivores (comparable to felids); their teeth were not as effective at cutting meat as later groups of large mammalian predators. From Fowler, O.S. No one quite knew what to make of them. Skeletons of terrestrial cetaceans and the relationship of whales to artiodactyls. However, the limb bones are quite dense, a trait that aquatic animals use to keep from floating to the surface. Contributions are fully tax-deductible. A later genus, Pachyaena, entered North America by the earliest Eocene, where it evolved into species that were at least as large. These "wolves on hooves" are an extinct order of carnivorous mammals, closely related to artiodactyls. pastor tom mount olive baptist church text messages / london drugs broadway and vine / mesonychids limbs and tail.
mesonychids limbs and tail American Museum Novitates 3344, 1-53. The prezygapophyses should be the ones with the articular surfaces directed medially, and the postzygapophyses those with the articular surface directed laterally, more similar to the condition in other tetrapods (and mammals, according to Fowler, http://www.archive.org/details/introductiontoos1885flow). They were major predators in the Northern Hemisphere from shortly after the demise of the dinosaurs until about 30 million years ago, and the shape of their teeth resembled those of whales likeProtocetus. So, in the sheep figure, anterior is to the left and above.
mesonychids limbs and tail Inside, If you didn't know, I've been away. Read more about this topic: Mesonychids, Phylogeny and Evolutionary Relationships, Every man is in a state of conflict, owing to his attempt to reconcile himself and his relationship with life to his conception of harmony. Synoplotherium may also be part of this Harpagolestes-Mesonyx clade, and Zhou et al. 201-234.
Which embryo is human? - Exploratorium Beginning in 1983, paleontologists have. Pakicetus has not been found from deposits of the Tethys Sea but instead from adjacent river and floodplain deposits, which also yield bones of land dwelling mammals. Archaic ungulates ("Condylarthra"). fc alliance soccer club knoxville tn. Pakicetus inachus, a New Archaeocete (Mammalia, Cetecea) from the early-middle Eocene Kuldana Formation of Kohat (Pakistan). Thewissen, J.G.M and Hussain, S.T. The molars were laterally compressed and often blunt and were probably used for shearing meat or crushing bones.
Becoming_Whales.doc - Unit: Evolution Advanced Biology, Since other predators, such as creodonts and Carnivora, were either rare or absent in these animal communities, mesonychids most likely dominated the large predator niche in the Paleocene of eastern Asia. These later mesonychids had hooves, one on each toe, with four toes on each foot. New middle Eocene archaeocetes (Cetacea: Mammalia) from the Kuldana Formation of Northern Pakistan. In the meantime, scientists speculated about what the ancestors of whales might have been like. Reconstructions of pakicetids that followed the discovery of composite skeletons often depicted them with fur; however, given their close relationships with hippos, they more likely had sparse body hair. For previous articles on Paleogene mammals see And for other stuff on neat and obscure fossil mammals see Archibald, J. D. 1998. Triisodontidae[1]. [5], Most paleontologists now doubt that whales are descended from mesonychids, and instead suggest mesonychians are descended from basal ungulates, and that cetaceans are descended from advanced ungulates (Artiodactyla), either deriving from, or sharing a common ancestor with, anthracotheres (the semiaquatic ancestors of hippos). Technically speaking, the term "mesonychid" refers specifically only to the members of the family Mesonychidae, such as the species of the genus Mesonyx. Postcranial skeleton of the early Eocene mesonychid Pachyaena (Mammalia: Mesonychia). Pakicetus had a long snout; a typical complement of teeth that included incisors, canines, premolars, and molars; a distinct and flexible neck; and a very long and robust tail.
Untitled Document [eweb.furman.edu] 1992, O'Leary & Rose 1995, Rose & O'Leary 1995), and also widespread, with specimens being known from the Paleocene and Eocene of eastern Asia, the Eocene and perhaps Paleocene of North America, and the Eocene of Europe. Long-snouted marsupial martens and false thylacines, Marsupial 'bears' and marsupial sabre-tooths, Because it would be wrong not to mention a sperm whale named like a tyrannosaur, http://viergacht.deviantart.com/art/Harpagolestes-133779748, http://www.archive.org/details/introductiontoos1885flow, The Lab Leak Theory Was Dismissed As Trump Xenophobia - Now Deniers Say It Was Not Accepted Because of Trump Xenophobia, DAN5/P1: Homo Erectus Early Cranial Capacity Was More Like Australopiths Such As 'Lucy', DART Made A Big Difference In Ability To Accurately Calculate Asteroid Deflections, The Subsidies Paradox: Affordable Food Versus The Environment, Degrowth communism as asolution for climate change. See you there. With a short lower spine stiffened by revolute joints, they would have run with stiff backs like modern ungulates rather than bounding or loping with flexible spines like modern Carnivorans. Archaic ungulates ("Condylarthra"). They first appeared in the Early Paleocene, undergoing numerous speciation events during the Paleocene, and Eocene. & McKenna, M. C. 2007. Thus it is unclear if it was an active predator or if instead it ambushed unsuspecting prey that wandered too closely. One possible conclusion is that Andrewsarchus has been incorrectly classified. A startling discovery made in the arid sands of Pakistan announced by University of Michigan paleontologists Philip Gingerich and Donald Russell in 1981 finally delivered the transitional form scientists had been hoping for. A recent study found mesonychians to be basal euungulates most closely related to the "arctocyonids" Mimotricentes, Deuterogonodon and Chriacus. The bulla is the bone of the skull that formed the floor of a cavity that housed the middle ear ossicles (the malleus, incus, and stapes). Even better, two jaw fragments showed that the teeth ofPakicetuswere very similar to those of mesonychids. Vague similarities with other long, I read something annoying; always a good impetus for a blog entry. ScienceBlogs is a registered trademark of Science 2.0, a science media nonprofit operating under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. For this reason, scientists had long believed that mesonychids were the direct ancestor of Cetacea, but the discovery of well preserved hind limbs of archaic cetaceans, as well as more recent phylogenetic analyses now indicates that cetaceans are more closely related to hippopotamids and other artiodactyls than they are to mesonychids, and this result is consistent with many molecular studies. The mesonychids mentioned here are not, of course, the only members of the group. Mesonychia ("middle claws ") is an extinct taxon of small- to large-sized carnivorous ungulates related to artiodactyls. This really is the end. [7] Some genera may need revision to clarify the actual number of species or remove ambiguity about genera (such as Dissacus and Ankalagon).[5]. The sound passage via the external ear of Pakicetus was intact and was similar to that of other mammals. Even in so extreme a case as this, if the supply of insects were constant, and if better adapted competitors did not already exist in the country, I can see no difficulty in a race of bears being rendered, by natural selection, more and more aquatic in their structure and habits, with larger and larger mouths, till a creature was produced as monstrous as a whale. As a result, the back was relatively stiff, and Pachyaena would have been a stiff-legged runner, its gait perhaps more resembling that of a horse or antelope than that of a carnivoran. The link between other ungulates and whales is thought to be mesonychids, extinct four-legged mammals that sometimes feasted on fish at river edges. Whales originated from aquatic artiodactyls in the Eocene epoch of India. This conflict between the paleontological and molecular hypotheses seemed intractable. Darwin was widely ridiculed for this passage. Dissacus was a jackal- or wolf-sized mesonychid that occurred throughout the Northern Hemisphere during the Late Paleocene (more than ten species have been named). Your Privacy Rights Mesonychids are a mostly Eocene group that originated in the Paleocene; Mesonyx, from the Middle Eocene of North America, was the first member of the group to be named (Cope published the name in 1872), and it's still one of the most familiar mesonychians, by which I mean one of the kinds featured most frequently in the popular and semi-technical literature. His attention to such tiny details ultimately settled the identification of the sea monster. An unrelated early group of mammalian predators, the creodonts, also had unusually large heads and limbs that traded flexibility for efficiency in running; large head size may be connected to inability to use the feet and claws to help catch and process food, as many modern carnivorans do. Adapted fromWritten in Stone: Evolution, the Fossil Record, and Our Place in Nature, by Brian Switek. Works of art are attempts to fight out this conflict in the imaginative world.Rebecca West (18921983), Whatever may be our just grievances in the southern states, it is fitting that we acknowledge that, considering their poverty and past relationship to the Negro race, they have done remarkably well for the cause of education among us. This global catastrophe cleared the way for a major radiation of mammals. With a short lower spine stiffened by revolute joints, they would have run with stiff backs like modern ungulates rather than bounding or loping with flexible spines like modern Carnivorans. By the turn of the 20th century the oldest fossil whales were still represented byBasilosaurusand similar forms likeDorudonandProtocetus, all of which were fully aquaticthere were no fossils to bridge the gap from land to sea. But what kind of animal was it? > traditional characterisation as archaic,'inferior' Mesonychids fared very poorly at the close of the Eocene epoch, with only one genus, Mongolestes,[6] surviving into the Early Oligocene epoch. Yep, you are correct - a stupid error that I will now go correct, thanks.
Mesonyx - Wikipedia Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 26:355-370. Which embryo is human? This condition is called pachyosteosclerosis, and whales are the only mammals known to have such a heavily thickened involucrum. The current uncertainty may, in part, reflect the fragmentary nature of the remains of some crucial fossil taxa, such as Andrewsarchus. Pioneers who cleared land in Alabama and Arkansas frequently found enormous round bones. - . malleus, incus, stapes), which transmitted the sound to the organ of hearing. (f`0eib6bP! kA
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
54
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Parent 1 0 R
/Resources 6 0 R
/Contents 11 0 R
/Rotate -90
/MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ]
/CropBox [ 0 0 612 792 ]
>>
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageC /ImageI ]
/Font << /F2 8 0 R /F3 7 0 R /F4 9 0 R >>
/XObject << /Im1 13 0 R >>
/ExtGState << /GS1 14 0 R >>
/ColorSpace << /Cs9 10 0 R >>
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /Times-Bold
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /Times-Italic
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
[
/Indexed /DeviceRGB 255 12 0 R
]
endobj
11 0 obj
<< /Length 1039 /Filter /FlateDecode >>
stream
2007). There was rapturous applause, swooning, the delight of millions. Study of the rest of the skeleton also revealed thatIndohyushad bones marked by a similar kind of thickening, an adaptation shared by mammals that spend a lot of time in the water. However, they also found Dissacus to be paraphyletic with respect to other mesonychids, so further study and perhaps some taxonomic revision is needed [Greg Paul's reconstruction of Ankalagon shown in adjacent image]. harvnb error: no target: CITEREFJordiAnton2002 (, J. D. Archibald. Mesonychids possess unusual triangular molar teeth that are similar to those of Cetacea (whales and dolphins), especially those of the archaeocetes, as well as having similar skull anatomies and other morphologic traits. [2] Mesonychids first appeared in the early Palaeocene with the genus Dissacus. Unlike all modern and possibly all other fossil cetaceans, it had four fully functional, long legs. Now that we've all survived Judgment Day, we can stop looking for ways to stop the Terminators, and go back to the search for dark matter. Mesonychids [1] were the first mammalian carnivores after the extinction of the dinosaurs . A million years later livedAmbulocetus, an early whale with a crocodile-like skull and large webbed feet. 1995]. Asiatic Mesonychidae (Mammalia, Condylarthra). Mesonychids first appeared in the early Paleocene, went into a sharp decline at the end of the Eocene, and died out entirely when the last genus, Mongolestes, became extinct in the early Oligocene. For another, more detailed, article about Mesonychidae, see, Sarah L. Shelley, Thomas E. Williamson, Stephen L. Brusatte, Resolving the higher-level phylogenetic relationships of Triisodontidae (Condylarthra) within Placentalia, October 2015, Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (abstract), "New Mesonychid mammals found from lower Paleogene of Erlian Basin, Nei Mongol", "Carnivores, creodonts and carnivorous ungulates: Mammals become predators", 10.1671/0272-4634(2000)020[0387:ANSOAM]2.0.CO;2, "Mesonyx and the other mesonychid mesonychians (mesonychians part IV) | ScienceBlogs", "The position of Hippopotamidae within Cetartiodactyla", "Evidence from milk casein genes that cetaceans are close relatives of hippopotamid artiodactyls", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mesonychid&oldid=1115476645, This page was last edited on 11 October 2022, at 17:25. Richard Owen, a rising star in the academic community, carefully scrutinized every bone, and he even received permission to slice into the teeth to study their microscopic structure. What springs to mind when you think of a whale? To see new stuff (from July 2011 to present), click here. Nearly all mesonychids are, on average, larger than most of the Paleocene and Eocene creodonts and miacoid carnivorans. If the early ancestors of whales had large, broad tails, that could explain why they evolved such a unique mode of swimming. The molars were laterally compressed and often blunt, and were probably used for shearing meat or crushing bones. Throughout the Paleocene and Eocene, several genera, including Dissacus, Pachyaena and Mesonyx would radiate out from their ancestral home in Asia and into Europe and North America, where they would give rise to new mesonychid genera. They were endemic to North America and Eurasia during the Early Paleocene to the Early Oligocene, and were the earliest group of large carnivorous mammals in Asia. While later mesonychids evolved a suite of limb adaptations for running similar to those in both wolves and deer, their legs remained comparatively thick. It was a wolf-like animal, not the slick, seal-like animal that had originally been envisioned. Accept Cookies, Osteopathic Manipulative Medicine Research. Such muscles are consistent with webbed feet that were used for aquatic locomotion. Nature 413:277281. Together, these traits suggest that Pakicetus represents an early stage in the evolution of cetaceans, one where many running adaptations were retained but rarely used. For this reason, scientists had long believed that mesonychids were the direct ancestor of Cetacea, but the discovery of well-preserved hind limbs of archaic cetaceans, as well as more recent phylogenetic analyses[8][9][10] now indicate cetaceans are more closely related to hippopotamids and other artiodactyls than they are to mesonychids, and this result is consistent with many molecular studies. In fact, some fossil teeth that were once identified as mesonychids are now known to have come from archaeocetes.
Mesonychidae - Wikipedia The manus of Pachyaena gigantea (Mammalia: Mesonychia). The American Phrenological Journal and Miscellany, Vol. Mesonychians were long considered to be creodonts, but have now been removed from that order and placed in three families (Mesonychidae, Hapalodectidae, and Triisodontidae), either within their own order, Mesonychia, or within the order Condylarthra as part of the cohort or superorder Laurasiatheria. Living at about the same time as the remingtonocetids was another group of even more aquatically adapted whales, the protocetids. Archaeocetes had a double-pulley astragalus, confirming that cetaceans had evolved from artiodactyls. The molars were laterally compressed and often blunt, and were probably used for shearing meat or crushing bones. Diet: There don't seem to be very many reconstructions of these critters available online.http://viergacht.deviantart.com/art/Harpagolestes-133779748, Very nice, Viergacht! 2023 Smithsonian Magazine While the limb proportions and hoof-like phalanges indicate cursoriality, the limbs were relatively stout and show that it cannot have been a long-distance pursuit runner. The semi-aquatic otters and beavers, he claimed, were better alternative models for the earliest terrestrial ancestors of whales. 1988, the feature they thought united Andrewsarchus and Cetacea (they include a cladogram with a list of synapomorphies for each node (or at least for many)) was arrangement of incisors in a fore-and-aft line: early whales (and I'm not sure how many really early Cetaceans were known when they wrote) have all three incisors in a line, Andrewsarchus has M3 behind rather than beside M2, which they saw as an intermediate step towards the Cetacean condition. If mathematical, chemical, physical and other formulas are not displayed correctly on this page, please useFirefox or Safari, This article is about the prehistoric ungulate. View original page. It was assigned to Creodonta by Cope (1880); to Creodonta by Cope (1889); to Carnivora by Peterson (1919); to Mesonychia by Carroll (1988) and Zhou et al. Mesonychid dentition consisted of molars modified to generate vertical shear, thin blade-like lower molars, and carnassial notches, but no true carnassials. I think the prezygapophyses and postzygapophyses are incorrectly identified in the essay. To me, a layman, the skull compares much better to entelodonts than to *Mesonyx* and kin. For more than a century, our knowledge of the whale fossil record was so sparse that no one could be certain what the ancestors of whales looked like. Given that the hippopotamus is the closest living relative of cetaceans, Pakicetus and hippos may have inherited this behavior from their common ancestor. This, in combination with its inferred diet (see below) and inferred ability to walk on the bottom, suggests that it attacked its prey from below. homestead high school staff. Together they illustrate how the entire transition took place.
How Did Whales Evolve? | Science| Smithsonian Magazine Throughout the 1990s, the skeletons of more or less aquatically adapted ancient whales, or archaeocetes, were discovered at a dizzying pace. But, long ago, not all ungulates were herbivores. The skeleton of Pakicetus resembles those of many other even-toed hoofed mammals (e.g. 1998. [13][14] One possible conclusion is that Andrewsarchus has been incorrectly classified. That the whole South should commit itself to the principle that the colored people have a right to be educated is an immense acquisition to the cause of popular education.Fannie Barrier Williams (18551944), America loves the representation of its heroes to be not just larger than life, but stupendously, awesomely bigger than anything else. mesonychids limbs and tail. Mesonychids e.g. Though these creatures, such as Dimetrodon, looked like reptiles, they were actually the archaic precursors of mammals. Some mesonychids are reconstructed as predatory (comparable to canids), others as scavengers or carnivore-scavengers with bone-crushing adaptations to their teeth (comparable to the large hyenas), and some as omnivorous (comparable to pigs, humans, or black bears). Isotopic records from early whales and sea cows: contrasting patterns of ecological transition. However, even though they are similar in appearance to land animals, some consider Mesonychids to be ancestors of whales. - . Some mesonychids are reconstructed as predatory (comparable to canids), others as scavengers or carnivore-scavengers with bone-crushing adaptations to their teeth (comparable to the large hyenas), and some as omnivorous (comparable to pigs, humans, or black bears). For another, more detailed, article about Mesonychidae, see, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. However, as the order is also renamed for Mesonyx, the term "mesonychid" is now used to refer to members of the entire order Mesonychia and the species of other families within it. Glad you tooted. Plenum Press (New York), pp. Various genera and species coexisted in some locations, as hunters and omnivores or scavengers. Its tail was long and slender, with no evidence of use for swimming. mesonychids limbs and tail. Huxley replied that there could be little doubt thatBasilosaurusprovided clues as to the ancestry of whales. Geisler & McKenna (2007) found Ankalagon to be nested within a clade of Dissacus species, suggesting that it doesn't deserve generic separation after all.
Mesonychid | Detailed Pedia spy wednesday images pitt law grade distribution mesonychids limbs and tail. Riley Black But the conflict was not without hope of resolution. Cookie Settings. %PDF-1.2
%
Nature 458:E1-E4. Of course, there are a few others: Dissacusium and Jiangxia from the Asian Paleocene, Guiletes from the Asian Eocene, and Hessolestes from the North American Eocene. He tentatively assigned it the name Basilosaurus. Mesonychia ("middle claws") is an extinct taxon of small- to large-sized carnivorous ungulates related to artiodactyls.
Cats vs dogs: in terms of evolution, are we barking up the wrong tree? Mesonychids were out-competed by Hyenodonts coming from Africa during Lower Eocene, maybe. We are part of Science 2.0,a science education nonprofit operating under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. mesonychids limbs and tailokinawan sweet potato tempura recipe. The long-snouted and otter-like remingtonocetids appeared next, including small forms like the 46-million-year-oldKutchicetus. He envisioned a hypothetical cetacean ancestor easing itself into the shallows: We may conclude by picturing to ourselves some primitive generalized, marsh-haunting animals with scanty covering of hair like the modern hippopotamus, but with broad, swimming tails and short limbs, omnivorous in their mode of feeding, probably combining water plants with mussels, worms, and freshwater crustaceans, gradually becoming more and more adapted to fill the void place ready for them on the aquatic side of the borderland on which they dwelt, and so by degree being modified into dolphin-like creatures inhabiting lakes and rivers, and ultimately finding their way into the ocean. The phylogeny of the ungulates. Harpagolestes and Mesonyx appear to be sister-taxa, and the most derived of mesonychids (O'Leary & Geisler 1999, Geisler 2001, Thewissen et al. They are all placed in the order Cetartiodactyla alongside terrestrial even-toed ungulates (hoofed mammals). That's what he does!
Mesonychia | Fossil Wiki | Fandom Mesonychid taxonomy has long been disputed and they have captured . With the permission of the publisher, Bellevue Literary Press. 24 Jun . It was about the size of a large sea lion. Good remains of P. ossifraga show that it was a large animal of 60-70 kg [skull of Sinonyx jiashanensis from Late Paleocene China shown below, from Zhou et al.